The answer depends upon the reliability that is being demanded. In terms of performance, both intel core i5 gaming laptop and ryzen laptops come with great performance. However, for intel processors, one needs to decide on the generation that they’re getting.
Based on benchmark tests, the 8th gen intel core i5 gaming laptop wasn’t able to beat the ryzen 5 gaming laptop.
Not only in performance but since AMD laptops come with Radeon GPUs, the laptop was able to beat the likes of Intel UHD graphics. Moreover, in a handbrake test to convert a 4K video to 1080p, the AMD Ryzen 5 laptop was able to take the lead than the one with a Core i5 processor.
Again, the stats are for Ryzen 5 and 8th Gen Intel Core i5 laptop. However, these can be completely different if you proceed on purchasing a higher generation Intel processor. But keeping in mind the processing powers, you would still want to have AMD by your side since this offers to outclass performance.
The choice depends upon the users. Many users are comfortable with Intel systems since these come cheap and there are several laptops that come with Intel processors. On the other hand, you would need to balance the power between AMD processors so that you can have balanced workability.
Another thing to consider is that you can opt to upgrade Intel chips since there aren’t any AMD chips in the area. Though with the recent Threadripper chip introduced by AMD that offers up to 32 Cores, one can surely think of spending a lot to get a boosted performance.
In a nutshell, if you’re competing an 8th Gen Intel Core i5 with a Ryzen 5, then its better to choose the latter one. The reason is that it’s offering better results. Overall you can still switch to higher generation to get more power in which manner, the Intel chip would prove to be a reliable choice.
