Home Laptop Reviews Lenovo Legion 5 v/s ASUS TUF Gaming A17: Which is Better?

Lenovo Legion 5 v/s ASUS TUF Gaming A17: Which is Better?

by FTblog

You go over several factors in choosing the right kind of gaming laptop. We’ve seen a great deal of gaming laptops from several brands including ASUS, Lenovo, HP, etc. One always has a preference for brands based on the quality of the products.

ASUS gaming laptops have quite been in the spotlight based on their one of a kind specs, appeal and performance. On the other hand, Lenovo gaming laptops come with a superb performance of their own, making them a reliable choice.

Within these amazing laptops, the Lenovo Legion 5 and ASUS TUF Gaming A17 are worth mentioning. Since you probably won’t go for both of them, it’s time to narrow down the choice to see, which is better. Let’s find out:

Specs Overview:

Here are the general specs for both gaming laptops:

 Lenovo Legion 5ASUS TUF Gaming A17
ProcessorAMD Ryzen 5AMD Ryzen 5
Processing Speed3.0 GHz-4.0 GHz3.0 GHz-4.0 GHz
GPUNvidia GeForce 1660 TiNvidia GeForce 1660 Ti
RAM8GB8GB
SSD512GB512GB
Screen Size15.6”17.3”
DisplayFHD IPS, 144Hz, <3ms, 100% sRGB, DolbyVisionFHD 120Hz, 64% sRGB, AdaptiveSync

Performance

Performance matters a lot when it comes to gaming. You don’t want to experience lags or have any performance issues that would crash the game. That is why having a solid processor is something that you shouldn’t compromise on.

In this context, both Lenovo Legion 5 and ASUS TUF Gaming A17 offers superb performance. You can even find alternate versions for both laptops. The Legion 5 is also available with 10th Gen i5 whereas the A17 is available with Ryzen 7. The core performance is superb, and you’ll probably get the best out of both gaming laptops.

Display

This is where things get interesting. Since both are coming with almost the same specs, the display is the one thing that surely differentiates them. For starters, both these gaming laptops feature FHD display; however, A17 comes with 17.3” screen whereas the Legion 5 comes with 15”.

In terms of the screen display, the Legion 5 takes the lead, offering 99% sRGB colour gamut with over 144Hz to 240Hz refresh rate and below 3ms response rate that allows you to experience the best graphical experiences. On the other hand, even with an enlarged screen, the A17 only features 64% of sRGB colour coverage. Moreover, it isn’t optimal in terms of gaming.

Apart from that, the Legion 5 doesn’t offer coverage for Adobe RGB as well. It also has brightness issues, which is why it cannot be used outside. But narrowing down to the one that has the upper hand, we can say that the Legion 5 offers better results.

Cooling

Lenovo gaming laptops particularly the Legion series feature Legion Coldfront for cooling needs. The Legion 5 also comes with Coldfront 2.0 that allows dissipating heat. This is done with dual-channel fans alongside liquid crystal polymer coating blades. It also features Q Control 3.0 that allows you to calibrate between quiet, balance, and performance heat controls. It also features Dual Burn support inside thrusters for keeping your CPU and GPU cool.

On the other hand, the A17 features comprehensive cooling system. The performance as tested by tech geeks was promising as it showed lower heat signatures than other aluminium laptops. This is due to multiple heat pipes, 3 heatsinks and self-cleaning technology that gives the best performance. This is further elevated with the help of military-grade toughness that protects it from heat issues.

Keyboard

Another important element for any gaming laptop is a comfortable gaming keyboard. The Legion 5 features a great RGB lit gaming keyboard with TrueStrike technology, 100% anti-ghosting, and soft landing keys. The 1.5mm key travel with and deeper stroke provides smooth touch. It also features a larger Numpad, arrow keys and one-piece trackpad that gives it a great appeal while making it comfortable to use.

For ASUS TUF A17, you also get an enjoyable and immersive keyboard. The keys are well placed with RGB backlighting. It also features Precision Drivers and offers 20 million keypresses with Overstroke technology. The desktop inspired keyboard features highlighted WASD keys that will bound you to game nonstop.

Additional Perks

Now that we’ve gone through some of the major assessing factors, it’s time to look into additional perks that these gaming laptops offer.

Sound

With Legion 5, you get 2W Harmon Kardon speaker system integrated with Dolby Atmos headphone support. From three-dimensional sound to immersive clarity, you’re bound to rejoice every sound coming from games, music or videos.

The ASUS A17 comes with two upgraded speakers that have been amplified to offer 2.7x deeper bass. However, testing of the speakers didn’t give positive results. The treble was great whereas the bass was rather suppressed. Overall, the DTS Ultra Technology did offer a cinematic experience for headsets.

Like other ASUS gaming laptops, the ASUS TUF gaming comes with Armoury Crate that allows you to control everything from one location. It comes with profile personalization that can allow you to manage things according to your needs. On the other hand, you get Lenovo Vantage for gaming, making it easier to calibrate the CPU overclocking and GPU’s workability. It also allows to push frame rates or adjust for performance or battery.

Speaking of battery, both systems come with extended battery hours but the Legion 5 takes some lead with its fast-charging system allowing 50% charge in just 30 minutes. Both gaming laptops lack Thunderbolt 3, which is somewhat a drawback.

Final Verdict

It truly gets difficult when choosing between Lenovo gaming laptops and ASUS gaming laptops. Considering the factors assessed, we can say that the Lenovo Legion 5 holds a slight upper hand because of better brightness, sound, and battery efficiency. Both laptops are even in terms of performance. Testing them didn’t illustrate much of a difference so you can surely pick any of them based on your needs.

Related Articles

Leave a Comment